The Ultimate Checklist for Hiring Software Development Outsourcing Company

Finding the right IT outsourcing partner is critical for any business. Done right, it can help you cut costs, scale your digital products, boost efficiency, and bring fresh innovation to the table.

But with so many options out there, how do you know which company is the right fit?

You see, it’s not always about technical expertise. It’s about finding a partner who understands your goals, aligns with your company culture, and communicates transparently.

Whether you’re outsourcing locally or globally, making the right choice is crucial.

To help you navigate the process, we’ve compiled a practical checklist covering everything you need to know.

Let’s get started!

Why Hiring the Right IT Outsourcing Company Matters

The IT outsourcing market is thriving, with experts predicting impressive growth in the coming years.

For businesses in the US, outsourcing is at the core of operational strategy. Recent statistics reveal that 92% of G2000 companies (the world’s largest 2000 public companies) rely on IT outsourcing services.

Whether you’re a small business or a large enterprise, you must consider outsourcing IT services. However, don’t settle for anything short of the ideal IT outsourcing company. Why?

Here are some top reasons.

1. Cost Savings

When you think of an in-house team, you will consider time and money for recruiting, onboarding, and training your new resources.

With IT outsourcing, you can cut down all such costs, especially labor expenses, around 70% of total operation costs for many organizations. Moreover, you don't need to invest in additional infrastructure, IT equipment, and software tools. 

2. Alignment of Value Systems

It's great to find a vendor who shares your value systems and is aligned. It helps to create an atmosphere of trust and mutual understanding, which fosters a positive working relationship. It is also the foundation for a long-term relationship, leading to efficiency and productivity. 

3. Team Synergy

A cohesive team synergy ensures that your project is delivered on time and to the desired quality. It adds to transparent communication and fosters collaboration and smooth operations. 

4. Focus on Core Competencies

When you outsource IT services, you can free your internal resources who can direct their focus on innovation and core business functions. Moreover, internal teams will gain the bandwidth to concentrate on research & development and strategic initiatives.

The freeing of time helps to create an environment where there's more time for creativity, and businesses can find new solutions and surpass the competition. 

5. Access to Large Talent Pool

Outsourcing gives companies a better choice to access a larger, more skilled, and more diverse talent pool from across the globe. With more choices, it helps businesses access a global talent pool and find the perfect fit. 

6. Seamless Communication

You can resolve issues quickly with the right IT outsourcing vendor. Open communication helps improve feedback loops, regular updates, and understanding of project requirements. 

7. Infrastructure and Setup

An exceptional advantage of IT outsourcing is the ability to tap into a global talent pool of experts skilled in the latest technologies and industry best practices.

Additionally, you are assured of your IT infrastructure staying resilient, scalable, and ahead of the competition in an ever-evolving digital landscape.

8. Governance

Businesses expect vendors and partners to have mature governance in place. When you hire the right IT outsourcing vendor, they will ensure adherence to industry regulations and security protocols.

Moreover, as a business, you can benefit from proactive mitigation of risks related to operations, security, and service delivery. 

Checklist for Hiring the Best IT Outsourcing Company

Let’s begin with the checklist you’ve all been waiting for.

1. Define Your Project Requirements

Imagine this: you’re planning to build your dream home and looking for the perfect contractor. Where do you start?

That’s right, you sit down and map out your vision. What should your home have? What’s a definite no? You’ll consider the budget, the must-have gadgets, and, of course, the timeline.

Now, here’s the big question: without sharing these details, can your contractor turn your dream into reality? How will they know you want a cozy reading nook or that you’re not a fan of open shelving in the kitchen?

They can’t read minds, right?

The same goes for outsourcing your IT needs.

Like building your dream home, you must lay out a clear plan. Communicate your vision, define your must-haves, and set expectations upfront. With the right “contractor” (or IT outsourcing vendor or partner), you’ll be well on your way to building something amazing.

You must start by clearly defining the scope, goals, objectives, and deliverables for an IT outsourcing project. It will ensure that your project is successful.

For instance, when sharing your goal, you can share: "Our goal is to enhance system security and scalability while optimizing operational costs. We need a partner who can strengthen our cybersecurity framework, implement robust threat detection and prevention measures, and ensure compliance with industry standards, all while supporting seamless integration with cloud-based solutions."

Your potential partner will have a clearer picture of your business needs. On the other hand, you will be able to shortlist the ideal vendors.

During this stage, you can look at the various types of IT outsourcing and consider hiring the best fit. The three main types of IT outsourcing that you will come across are nearshore, onshore, and offshore. 

Here’s a quick peek for you.

Table 1: A matrix comparing Onshore, Nearshore, and Offshore IT Outsourcing based on key factors

• Onshore: Ideal for businesses requiring frequent in-person meetings, high security, and seamless communication despite the higher cost.
• Nearshore: Best for companies looking for a balance between cost, collaboration, and access to a slightly broader talent pool.
• Offshore: Perfect for cost-sensitive projects requiring a large talent pool and scalable solutions, where time zones and cultural differences can be managed effectively.

Let’s drill down further; you must plot your budget, timeline, and technology needs. 

Here are some key budget considerations to help you plan effectively:

A. Direct Costs

• Service Fees: Outline the cost of the IT services you plan to outsource, including vendor pricing and contract terms.
• Technology Investments: Account for any new tools, software, or infrastructure required to support the outsourced service.

B. Indirect Costs

• Internal Management Time: Estimate the time and effort your internal team will spend coordinating with the outsourcing vendor, managing the transition, and maintaining ongoing collaboration.
• Potential Disruptions: Assess the risks of operational delays or disruptions during the transition phase and prepare for contingency measures.

You must also be detailed about the specific technologies you’re using or planning to adopt. This includes software, platforms, and technical skills critical to your business. 

Here are some key technology aspects that you must detail and discuss. 

• Infrastructure: Cloud services (AWS, Azure, GCP), on-premise vs. cloud strategy, server management.
• Software Development: Preferred programming languages (Java, Python, .NET), frameworks, and methodologies (Agile, DevOps).
• Cybersecurity: Data protection strategies, security certifications (ISO 27001, GDPR compliance).
• Integration Needs: Integration with existing legacy systems or third-party software.

Bottomline: By having a structured conversation around these points, you can ensure your outsourcing partner understands your technical needs and can offer solutions that align with your business goals, providing long-term value and support. 

2. Evaluate Vendor Expertise and Experience

Once you have your vision, goals, objectives, budget, timeline, etc., it's time to carefully evaluate the IT outsourcing companies based on multiple factors as it will help shortlist the ideal ones. Here are some key considerations.

A) Expertise and Domain Knowledge

• Industry-Specific Experience: Consider companies that have proven experience in your industry. For example, healthcare, finance, and retail often have unique technical and compliance requirements.
• Technical Expertise: Another key consideration is looking for companies specializing in the specific technologies you require, such as cloud computing, cybersecurity, or software development.

B) Evaluate Certifications, Case studies, and Portfolio

It will help to have a holistic drill down on the portfolios, certifications, case studies, and more. Here’s a detailed checklist that will come in handy.

#Evaluate Basic Profile

A good place to start is by checking the vendor’s basic profile.

• How many years has the vendor been in the software development industry?
• How many years have they been offering services to offshore countries?
• What is the company’s business model?
• What are their core values?
• What are their key services and areas of expertise?

#Check Client lists and References

Client lists and references offer valuable insights into the quality of deliverables. Moreover, you will clearly understand the types of projects and clients the vendor has successfully managed.

• How many clients have they handled?
• Which countries or regions are their clients from?
• Have they handled and completed projects similar to your business needs?

#Check Certifications

Certifications validate a vendor’s expertise, adherence to industry standards, and commitment to best practices. 

• Do the certifications align with the services you need?
• Are they specific to key areas such as cybersecurity (e.g., ISO 27001, SOC 2), cloud expertise (e.g., AWS Certified, Microsoft Azure certifications), or software development (e.g., Agile, DevOps certifications)?
• How recent are these certifications, and are they still valid?
• Are they certified in compliance with relevant regulatory standards such as GDPR, HIPAA, or PCI DSS, depending on your business requirements?
• Do their certifications demonstrate adherence to global IT standards like ITIL or CMMI?
• Are they certified partners or premium providers for major platforms (e.g., AWS Partner Network, Microsoft Gold Partner, Google Cloud Partner)?

#Check Third-Party Ratings

Third-party platforms provide unbiased insights into a vendor’s reputation. Evaluate these ratings critically to gain an objective view of their performance.

• What are their ratings on trusted platforms like Clutch, G2, or Gartner?
• Are there specific areas where they excel, such as customer service, technical expertise, or on-time delivery?
• How does their rating compare to competitors in the same space?
• Are there recurring concerns or red flags in the reviews?

Bottomline: By thoroughly evaluating case studies, third-party ratings, and certifications, you can ensure the vendor’s credibility and capability to deliver on your IT outsourcing needs. 

3. Check References and Testimonials

It will also help to drill down further on references and client testimonials to check the potential partner’s credibility.

#Check References

Contact past clients directly to validate the vendor’s claims. This step offers first-hand insights into their reliability and working style.

• Were they able to meet deadlines and stay within budget?
• How was their communication and responsiveness throughout the project?
• Did the vendor provide support after project delivery?
• Were there any unexpected challenges, and how did they handle them?

#Check Testimonials and Case Studies

You can dig deeper when it comes to reviews. Don’t just skim through glowing reviews. Look for specific examples in testimonials or case studies that align with your business needs.

• Are the testimonials from businesses in your industry or with similar challenges?
• Do the case studies showcase measurable outcomes, such as cost savings, improved efficiency, or faster delivery?
• Can the vendor provide detailed case studies on projects of a similar scale or complexity to yours?
• Look for patterns in client feedback—are there consistent mentions of strengths like communication, problem-solving, or innovation?

4. Assess Communication and Collaboration

Building strong connections with your vendors is essential, but what truly matters is effectively communicating your needs, expectations, and feedback promptly.

The ultimate goal should foster strong communication and collaboration, creating a foundation for mutually beneficial, long-term relationships.

The key lies in promoting open dialogue and cultivating a culture of transparency and trust. Establishing regular communication channels—such as scheduled meetings, collaboration tools, and email updates—can help resolve issues quickly and allow for timely feedback.

Defining the frequency of communication, preferred methods, and designated points of contact ensures clarity and consistent progress toward your goals.

In this context, a Deloitte report highlights that communication-related factors are among the top qualitative traits businesses seek in vendors, emphasizing the importance of prioritizing these values when selecting and working with your partners.

Image 1: Top qualitative aspects you must value in a service provider

Cultural differences can sometimes lead to misunderstandings, conflicts, or concerns like project delays and reduced productivity. These challenges highlight the importance of focusing on cultural and time-zone alignment when working with IT outsourcing vendors.

Misaligned time zones can complicate scheduling meetings and hinder daily communication. While convenient at times, asynchronous communication can result in confusion and further misunderstandings. 

Additionally, limited overlapping working hours can make it challenging to address urgent issues promptly. You may want a practical approach to overcoming problems around overlapping work hours. 

For example, If a US team works from 9 AM to 5 PM EST and a Philippine team works from 9 AM to 6 PM PHT (+08), the core overlap time would be:

• US Time: 9 PM - 12 AM EST
• Philippine Time: 10 AM - 1 PM PHT (+08)

In such a scenario, you must find out the core working hours of both teams. Next, identify when both teams are available and set aside hours for discussions, daily meetings, and urgent mitigation of issues. 

To navigate these challenges, tools like World Time Buddy can help track time zones and schedule meetings effectively. However, the real key lies in hiring vendors with strong cultural alignment. This ensures smoother collaboration, better communication, and faster problem-solving, ultimately leading to more productive and successful partnerships.

Bottomline: You must establish proper communication protocols and consider cultural compatibility with your chosen outsourcing team. It can significantly influence collaboration, communication, and productivity. 

5. Analyze Cost and Budget Transparency

During project initiation, you likely already outlined your budget considerations. When shortlisting an IT outsourcing vendor, requesting a detailed cost breakdown of the outsourcing services is essential. You must thoroughly understand both the direct and hidden costs associated with outsourcing. This comprehensive understanding will help you evaluate any perceived cost barriers effectively. 

When evaluating IT outsourcing costs, consider the following:

1. Differential Cost Analysis

This involves comparing the cost of outsourcing with the cost of performing the same services in-house.

2. Opportunity Cost Analysis

This analysis examines the benefits or opportunities you forgo when choosing one option over another, such as outsourcing versus in-house operations.

3. Incremental Cost Analysis

Incremental cost, also known as marginal cost, refers to the additional financial impact of a decision—such as scaling up operations—on your company’s financials. It accounts for extra expenses incurred when adjusting your operational approach, such as adding new services or scaling teams.

Hidden Costs to Consider

A critical aspect of cost evaluation is identifying hidden costs, which can include unforeseen expenses not explicitly outlined in vendor contracts. While many vendors are transparent about their pricing, you should remain vigilant about hidden costs such as:

• Setup fees
• Data migration costs
• Charges for exceeding service limits

Practical Tips for Managing Outsourcing Costs

1. Prepare a Comprehensive Budget: Ensure your budget includes all potential costs, including hidden ones.
2. Request a Detailed Cost Breakdown: Negotiate terms upfront to minimize the risk of unexpected expenses.
3. Monitor Expenses Continuously: Track costs regularly and address hidden charges as early as possible.

Bottomline: By following these steps, you can make informed decisions, mitigate risks, and maximize the value of your outsourcing partnership.

6. Assess Technology and Tools

Yet another vital aspect you need to focus on is understanding the current state of your infrastructure. This will involve researching the technical standards, tools, technologies, regulations, policies, and practices that govern the infrastructure. 

The insights will help you determine the readiness for change within the organization and communicate it effectively with your potential partner. You can next assess how the vendor plans for a smooth transition to maintain compatibility of the existing systems with the new ones.

Actively look out for partners who acknowledge the role of up-to-date tools for scalability. The partners who appreciate this facet will help your business manage data, grow, and maintain efficiency. 

Bottomline: Assessing your existing infrastructure for compatibility and embracing scalability will be a strategic investment that will help keep your business resilient in a competitive landscape. 

7. Ensure Data Security and Compliance

When looking for potential IT outsourcing vendors, verify their adherence to the relevant regulations like GDPR and HIPAA. To gain insights, you can conduct vendor assessments and perform regular security audits and compliance checks. 

Outsourcing raises security concerns over confidential data and intellectual property. Thus, you need a partner who understands your concerns and ensures you stay obligated to protect the IP.  

To protect your most valuable assets, you can closely monitor the provider's compliance and include robust intellectual property provisions in outsourcing contracts. It will help to protect you from any misappropriation or infringement. 

Bottomline: Finding a partner who fosters a secure environment to safeguard data privacy, intellectual property, and proprietary information is essential.

8. Evaluate Post-Project Support

Post-project, you need support, which refers to the ongoing assistance and maintenance offered after the completion of the project. This stage has many aspects, and it involves proactively managing issues that may arise with the software.

An IT outsourcing vendor who can ensure the smooth functioning of the software with consistent updates, bug fixes, and enhancements will guarantee you value over time. 

When evaluating the ongoing support that you may need - here are some quick questions that you may need to ask: 

General Support:

• What are the standard support hours?
• What is the procedure for escalating when complex issues arise?
• What is the typical response time for issues with different severity levels?
• What are the communication channels that are available (phone, email, live chat)?

Remote Access and Troubleshooting:

• How does the support team access the systems remotely when troubleshooting?
• What tools are used for remote access and control?

Training and Knowledge Base:

• Are user training or onboarding sessions offered for new users?
• Is there a readily accessible online knowledge base or documentation?
• How are new features and updates communicated to users?

Service Level Agreements (SLAs):

• What should you expect in terms of response times and resolution times outlined in the SLA?
• How are SLAs monitored and reported on?
• What happens if the vendor fails to meet your SLA commitments?

Incident Management:

• What system is used for incident reporting and status updates?
• How is the communication done for users regarding major outages or system issues?

Bottomline: Finding a partner who fosters a secure environment to safeguard data privacy, intellectual property, and proprietary information is essential.

Common Red Flags to Watch Out For

When selecting an IT outsourcing vendor, here are some red flags to watch out for. 

Red flag #1: Vague communication 

You must consider whether the vendor avoids answering questions directly or is vague and lacks clarity. These are signs of vague communication and poor communication practices.

Red flag #2: Lack of transparency

When a vendor is unable to provide detailed information about their processes, methodologies, or team structure. Moreover, if the vendor is hesitant to offer the needed information, it is a red flag.

Red flag #3: Unclear pricing

You need to be cautious of vendors who are ambiguous with terms of pricing or hidden costs. This could lead to unexpected expenses later during the project cycle.

Red flag #4: Weak security practices

Let's say the vendor has no plan for robust data security measures or cannot present information about this, which could mean your sensitive information is at risk. 

Download and follow the checklist for finding a trusted and reliable IT outsourcing partner.

Outsource Software Development with Imaginovation

Ready to transform your software development project into a game-changing solution? If you’re excited but unsure where to begin, consider partnering with Imaginovation—a multi-award-winning web and mobile app development company based in Raleigh.

At Imaginovation, we excel in creating futuristic digital solutions powered by emerging technologies. Our team specializes in developing cutting-edge applications tailored to meet your unique business needs.

Let’s bring your vision to life—contact us today!